Translators - Translator Resources
ProZ.com – Globales Verzeichnis von Übersetzungsdiensten
 The translation workplace

Deutsch: Deutschtum

Englisch translation: German culture







KudoZ
The KudoZ network provides a framework for translators... More



Glossareintrag (aus Frage unten abgeleitet)
Deutsch Begriff oder Satz:Deutschtum
Englisch Übersetzung:German culture
Eingetragen von:Chris Rowson
Optionen:
- Zu diesem Eintrag beitragen

7:14am May 17, 2006Login or register (free) for more options.
Übersetzungen Deutsch > Englisch [PRO]
Art/Literary - Musik
Deutsch Begriff oder Satz: Deutschtum
"Neben Franz Schubert, Johannes Brahms, Richard Wagner und dem einheimischen Karl Mayrberger setzte sich die „Preßburger Liedertafel“ speziell für die Werke Franz Liszts ein, dessen vielschichtige Persönlichkeit ungarischen Patriotismus, Deutschtum und Internationalität vereinte."

This is from a brief item about German choral music in Pressburg in the mid-19th century. I have a rough idea about what is happening there politically, and about Franz/Ferenc Liszt, I just have no idea how to translate "Deutschtum". All contributions gratefully received.
Chris Rowson
Deutschland
Notiz(en) an den/des Fragesteller(s)
Sabine Griebler: 7:25am May 17, 2006: Preßburg is Bratislava today. -
Richard Benham: 10:11am May 17, 2006: Sabine is right, but I am not sure this should make too much difference. Maybe put "(now Bratislava, Slovakia)" after the name on first mention. If it's an historic piece its name and affiliations at the time are more important. -

identification with German culture
Erklärung:
I'm going to go out on a rather shaky limb here, but I really don't find the word "Germanness" or "Germanism" particularly appealing.

...united Hungarian patriotism, his identification with German culture and the international community.

Another option, which is perhaps safer, is "identification with Germany." But for whatever reason I don't like it as much.

Ultimately we have an artist here, so it's unlikely that he identified with German aggression, for example, especially if he was a Hungarian patriot, so with that in mind it seems plausible that what is meant here by Deutschtum is in fact primarily its culture.
Ausgewählte Antwort von:

Henry Schroeder
Vereinigte Staaten
Hinweis von Fragesteller an den Antwortenden
Thanks to everyone for your contributions. I really don´t feel happy with the “German-” words, they don´t seem like real words to me, so I was happy to use Henry´s suggestion: “ … united Hungarian patriotism, German culture and internationalism.”
4 KudoZ-Punkte wurden für diese Antwort vergeben



ZUSAMMENFASSUNG ALLER ÜBERSETZUNGEN (ENGLISCH)
2 +8Germanness
Alan Johnson
2 +2identification with German culture
Henry Schroeder
3Germanity
Lori Dendy-Molz
3Germanism
Steffen Walter
3GermanessBrigitteHilgner


  


Antworten

5 Min.   Antwortsicherheit: Answerer confidence 3/5Answerer confidence 3/5
Germaness

Erklärung:
My spontaneous idea - supported by Pons/Collins Großwörter- buch

BrigitteHilgner
Österreich
Muttersprache: Deutsch
PRO-Punkte in Kategorie: 4

Kommentare zu dieser Antwort (und Antworten vom Beantworter der Frage)
Neutraler Kommentar Steffen Walter: German*n*ess
6 Min.
  -> Thank you Steffen! You are perfectly right - one of my infamous typos. :-)
Login to enter a peer comment (or grade)


8 Min.   Antwortsicherheit: Answerer confidence 2/5Answerer confidence 2/5 Zustimmung (Netto): +8
Germanness

Erklärung:
Is how I would probably interpret this. I see it as being similar to his "ungarischen Patriotismus". He was both a Hungarian and a German patriot. But this is mere guesswork as I know nothing about classical musicians.

Alan Johnson
Deutschland
Muttersprache: Englisch

Kommentare zu dieser Antwort (und Antworten vom Beantworter der Frage)
Zustimmung David Moore
3 Min.

Zustimmung Steffen Walter: http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9807E4D7153DF...
5 Min.

Zustimmung Matthias Quaschning-Kirsch
11 Min.

Zustimmung Alison Jenner
45 Min.

Zustimmung xxxFrancis Lee: Liszt was a classic binational product of Austria-Hungary - plus his daughter married Wagner; "Germanness" is fine IMO
1 Stunde

Zustimmung Bianca AH: FYI far more hits on googlefight for Germanness than Germanity. Just for a bit of fun...
1 Stunde

Zustimmung Ingeborg Gowans
4 Stunden

Zustimmung mbrodie
8 Stunden
Login to enter a peer comment (or grade)


11 Min.   Antwortsicherheit: Answerer confidence 3/5Answerer confidence 3/5
Germanism

Erklärung:
See examples:
http://www.commentarymagazine.com/Summaries/V75I4P57-1.htm
http://www.bookrags.com/ebooks/4234/
(ironically enough, these comments relate to Richard Wagner not Franz Liszt)

Steffen Walter
Deutschland
Muttersprache: Deutsch
PRO-Punkte in Kategorie: 15

Kommentare zu dieser Antwort (und Antworten vom Beantworter der Frage)
Neutraler Kommentar David Moore: It's just BECAUSE Wagner was German that my gut tells me this not the correct way to express the "Deutschtum" concept as displayed by the foreigner, Liszt.
3 Min.
Login to enter a peer comment (or grade)


24 Min.   Antwortsicherheit: Answerer confidence 2/5Answerer confidence 2/5 Zustimmung (Netto): +2
identification with German culture

Erklärung:
I'm going to go out on a rather shaky limb here, but I really don't find the word "Germanness" or "Germanism" particularly appealing.

...united Hungarian patriotism, his identification with German culture and the international community.

Another option, which is perhaps safer, is "identification with Germany." But for whatever reason I don't like it as much.

Ultimately we have an artist here, so it's unlikely that he identified with German aggression, for example, especially if he was a Hungarian patriot, so with that in mind it seems plausible that what is meant here by Deutschtum is in fact primarily its culture.

Henry Schroeder
Vereinigte Staaten
Arbeitsgebiet
Muttersprache: Englisch
PRO-Punkte in Kategorie: 36
Hinweis von Fragesteller an den Antwortenden
Thanks to everyone for your contributions. I really don´t feel happy with the “German-” words, they don´t seem like real words to me, so I was happy to use Henry´s suggestion: “ … united Hungarian patriotism, German culture and internationalism.”

Kommentare zu dieser Antwort (und Antworten vom Beantworter der Frage)
Zustimmung Frosty: Could be, but that doesn`t mean this is not the most appropriate translation!
2 Stunden
  -> The general consensus however does not seem to be with us.

Zustimmung Ian M-H
2 Tage2 Stunden
Login to enter a peer comment (or grade)


29 Min.   Antwortsicherheit: Answerer confidence 3/5Answerer confidence 3/5
Germanity

Erklärung:
...another option

I will argue that Nietzsche's understanding of Germanity is more ... Zarathustra's Germanity is of paramount importance to determining the cultural ...
muse.jhu.edu/journals/journal_of_nietzsche_studies/v027/27.1westfall.html

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 32 mins (2006-05-17 07:46:18 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

a few refs in context:

(Josef Danhauser, Liszt am Flugel, 1840, Nationalgalerie Berlin.) ... As we'll see, the American course stands as an expression of Germanity against the ...
mheffley.web.wesleyan.edu/almatexts/almamusicology/germanchaps2-4/almachap2a.htm - 337k - Cached - Similar pages

almacdnarr
... giving a kind of symmetry of ritual to the LP's concept, and a nice slice of Germanity. ... and propagated through Chopin and especially Liszt. ...
mheffley.web.wesleyan.edu/almatexts/almamusicosophy/almacdnarr.htm - 513k - Cached - Similar pages

The Project Gutenberg EBook of Richard Wagner, by John F. Runciman ...
As yet I have said nothing about his acquaintance with Liszt. ... 1844--in its assertion of the Germanity of Weber and Weber's music; and his deep joy that ...
www.gutenberg.org/files/16431/16431.txt

Lori Dendy-Molz
Deutschland
Muttersprache: Englisch
PRO-Punkte in Kategorie: 16

Kommentare zu dieser Antwort (und Antworten vom Beantworter der Frage)
Neutraler Kommentar Ian M-H: I'm not convinced that this is more than a made-up word, which may work in some contexts but is probably best avoided
2 Tage2 Stunden
Login to enter a peer comment (or grade)





Zur KudoZ-Liste zurückkehren